My husband gave them an address I knew by heart. The moment I recognized it, everything changed.

And they found another notebook.

This one was older.

Inside were notes that connected the six previous subjects to specific adults who had helped Evelyn obtain access to them.

Several names were crossed out.

Some were marked with short comments.

One word appeared again and again.

TRANSFER.

The investigator told me they were still determining exactly what had happened to each child, but the evidence showed that Evelyn had been planning these sessions for much longer than anyone had realized.

Then he showed me something that made my hands go numb.

A page from the second notebook contained a list of future subjects.

My daughter was not the only infant on it.

There were three more entries.

Three families.

Three babies.

And beside each one was information about when the mother would be alone, when the father would be working, and who could be trusted to bring the child to Evelyn.

I recognized one of the names.

A woman from our neighborhood.

She had congratulated me when my daughter was born.

She had even asked about the baby’s feeding schedule.

At the time, I thought she was being friendly.

Now I understood why she had been asking.

The investigation widened that afternoon.

Police contacted the other families connected to the notebooks. Some refused to believe what they were hearing. Others immediately remembered strange appointments Evelyn had arranged.

One mother told investigators her baby had developed unexplained burns months earlier.