At my sister’s special celebration, a family argument crossed the line. Then my parents told me I should be the one to apologize.

I thought about the broken river. My college fund. My wedding. The $18,000. Forty hours in that parking garage. The empty sage room.

“No.”

Nolan nodded once.

Then he unlocked his phone.

Chapter 2

I stood slowly while Nolan steadied my elbow, and the entire tent became quiet. Tessa seemed almost relieved at first; she thought Nolan was going to show everyone the video of her shoving me.

Instead, I opened the folder he had named Round Four.

“This is the picture Tessa posted last January,” I said. “Most of you shared it.”

I enlarged the wrist.

“Tessa, hold up your left hand.”

She didn’t move.

Eventually she raised it. Her wrist was smooth.

“The woman in this photograph has a sparrow tattoo. Tessa doesn’t.”

For perhaps two seconds, nobody made a sound.

Then Tessa rolled her eyes. “I used a stock photo. I didn’t want my actual arm with a needle in it all over Facebook. Is that illegal now?”

“It isn’t a stock photo.”

I showed them Hannah Merritt’s original post from Oregon, dated 2021.

Tessa spread her hands toward the guests. “Fine. I borrowed a picture.”

Aunt Patty actually nodded, as if borrowing somebody else’s chemotherapy photograph were merely a questionable decorating choice.

Then Nolan swiped.

I showed them Nashville.

The rooftop. The date. The drinks. The pink cowboy hat.

And my green suede jacket.

Tessa stared at the screen.

“I rescheduled treatment.”

Dad finally spoke.

“You said you were at Kayla’s apartment because you couldn’t stand up.”

“Daddy—”

“You said you couldn’t stand up.”

Tessa’s face collapsed into tears, but instead of answering she pointed at me.

“This is jealousy. She’s been jealous of me forever. She can’t have a baby, so she can’t stand that I might get one.”

It was cruel enough that several people instinctively looked away from me.

Mom stepped forward. “Gina, that’s enough.”

Then Donna Fischer stood up.

Donna had been my mother’s best friend for thirty years and an oncology nurse for twenty-five. She had spent most of the party seated near the recycling bins because, I later realized, Mom had deliberately kept her away from Tessa.

Tessa was insisting that everyone call Dr. Hollander and ask for her records.

Donna stopped beside the patio.

“Mark Hollander?”

Tessa turned.

“I worked with Mark Hollander for ten years,” Donna said gently. “He retired in 2023.”

Tessa froze.

Donna looked at the wide neckline of my sister’s blouse.

“You also said your port is still in. With that shirt, I should be able to see the bump or at least the scar from here.”

She touched the area beneath her own collarbone.

“There’s nothing there, honey.”

The crowd changed then.

Not loudly. Nobody started screaming or throwing accusations. People simply stopped offering Tessa explanations she could hide inside.

Aunt Patty tried one last defense.