“I know you did not,” Connor replied with a solemn expression.
“How could that possibly be?” I pressed, needing an immediate answer. “Because eventually Bridget managed to contact me directly through the military postal service,” Connor revealed.
“Bridget contacted you directly?” I asked, thoroughly stunned by the claim.
“She told me that you had already moved on with your life,” Connor said, watching my reaction closely. “No, I never moved on from you,” I vehemently denied.
“She explicitly said you were seeing someone else seriously,” Connor continued, his voice heavy with sadness. “She told me you did not want me suddenly showing up out of nowhere and ruining your vibrant new life.” I stood up from the sofa, pacing across the polished hardwood floor. “That whole story does not make any logical sense.”
“I thought it sounded wrong back then too,” Connor admitted, looking up at me.
“Then why did you not just come back to Florida anyway to verify it yourself?” I demanded. “I actually tried finding you a year later,” Connor explained quickly. “However, you had completely relocated without leaving a forwarding address.”
“Because Bridget convinced me to move away with her!” I exclaimed as the horrific realization washed over me. Connor nodded his head slowly in solemn agreement. “That was entirely the point of her scheme.” I felt intensely sick to my stomach as the world seemed to spin around me. Then he added a specific detail that made his tragic story almost impossible not to believe. “I honestly think she secretly wanted me for herself back when we were young.”
“What are you saying?” I asked in absolute disbelief. “She was always deeply jealous of our romance,” Connor claimed with conviction. “No, that cannot be true,” I countered instantly. “Bridget married your closest friend from high school.”
“She married him eventually, yes, but only after she realized I was out of her reach,” Connor countered smoothly.
I stared down at him, my heart pounding in my chest. “Do you still have those cruel letters she sent you?”
His facial expression changed instantly, softening into a look of heavy regret. “I burned them all years ago.”
“You burned every single one of them?” I questioned, searching his face.
“I simply could not bear to keep reading the cruel words that stole you away from me,” Connor explained softly. It sounded deeply heartbreaking and romantic at that exact moment. At the time, I truly believed every single word that spilled from his mouth.
Bridget called my phone that very evening around seven o’clock. I immediately declined the incoming call without answering. She tried calling me again just ten minutes later. I promptly turned my mobile phone completely off and tossed it onto the kitchen counter. The next morning, my sister drove over and knocked firmly on my front door. “Abby? Please open up, I know you are sitting inside.” I stood silently behind the living room curtain and refused to move a single muscle.
Connor gently touched my right shoulder from behind. “Please do not hate your own sister because of me.” I turned around and looked at him in disbelief. “She literally stole fifty-five precious years of happiness from us.” “We do not have enough years left in this world to waste them on hatred,” Connor whispered sweetly, stroking my cheek. That single wise sentence convinced me of his purity more than anything else he had said so far. What terrible liar would defend the very villain who had ruined his entire life? If only I had known back then that I was asking all the wrong questions.
Over the next three busy weeks, Connor and I somehow became nineteen years old all over again. Or at least, we pretended we were. We stayed up talking until midnight every single evening, fondly remembering old mutual friends I had long forgotten and nostalgic places in town that no longer existed. “Do you remember that tiny roadside diner off the main highway?” he asked one night over hot tea. “Of course I do,” I replied with a bright smile. “Do you remember spilling a whole chocolate milkshake down the front of my white dress?” “You were the one who accidentally bumped my arm,” Connor argued playfully.
“You bumped into me because you were busy staring at the pretty young waitress,” I teased back.
“I was staring directly at you the whole night,” Connor insisted softly.
I laughed out loud. “You are still a terrible liar after all these years.” Suddenly, his mobile phone buzzed loudly on the wooden coffee table between us. Connor glanced down at the glowing screen briefly and immediately turned the device facedown.
“Are you not going to answer that?” I asked curiously.
“No, it is fine,” he dismissed quickly.
“Who was calling you at this late hour?” I inquired. “Just someone calling from my old life up north,” Connor replied smoothly. There was a strange, subtle shift in his tone of voice that made me pause for a brief moment.
Then he smiled warmly and reached across the table to take my hand. “That old life does not matter to me anymore, Abby. This new life with you is the only thing that matters.” I wanted to believe his sweet words so desperately that I completely suppressed my lingering doubts.
A few nights later, Connor held both of my hands as we sat together on the back porch. “Why are we merely dating like teenagers at seventy-five years old?” I laughed softly at his dramatic tone. “What else should two senior citizens be doing?”
“We should be getting married without wasting another moment,” Connor stated plainly. I stared at him in utter shock. “Connor, we are practically already old…”
“You are already my true wife in my heart,” Connor interrupted tenderly.
For the very first time in fifty-five long years, I stopped dwelling on everything I had lost in my youth and started focusing intensely on how much quality time I might still have left.
We quickly planned a small, intimate backyard wedding ceremony for our close family. Connor insisted on having the wedding very soon. In fact, he wanted it held within the week. He also suddenly started asking very practical financial questions about my personal affairs. “Is this house fully paid off, Abby?” “Yes, I paid off the mortgage twenty years ago,” I answered honestly.
“Do you happen to have an updated legal will drawn up?” Connor asked casually over morning coffee.
“Why are you asking me about legal documents all of a sudden?” I inquired, raising an eyebrow.
“We are certainly not twenty years old anymore, sweetheart,” Connor explained calmly. “We ought to know exactly how to take care of each other financially if something happens.” “You have obviously thought about this financial matter a lot,” I noted, watching his calm composure. “About our long-term security together? Of course I have,” Connor answered smooth as silk.
“I specifically meant the property and money side of things,” I clarified. He offered a charming smile. “They are essentially the same exact thing at our advanced age, Abby.” It made logical sense when he framed it like that. At least, I desperately wanted it to make sense at the time.
The day right before our scheduled backyard wedding, I invited my immediate family over to my home and officially announced our big surprise. “Connor and I are getting married right here tomorrow afternoon,” I proclaimed to the living room. Everyone in the room started talking at once in absolute excitement and disbelief. Suddenly, the front door opened and Bridget walked straight inside. She stepped out into the sunlit backyard, caught sight of Connor standing next to me, and stopped dead in her tracks.
Connor leaned close to my ear and whispered, “That right there is the exact face of a guilty woman who never expected her wicked lie to walk through the door.” Bridget looked directly at me with horror in her eyes. “Abby, you absolutely cannot marry that man!” I let out a bitter, cold laugh. “Oh, so now you suddenly care about my happiness?”
“Please listen to me, Abby,” Bridget pleaded, stepping closer.
“You knew he was alive this whole time!” I yelled at her, my voice shaking with rage.
Her pale face changed instantly as she turned her head. “Who on earth told you such a ridiculous story?”
“Connor told me everything,” I declared proudly.
Bridget locked eyes with Connor for a long second. Then she turned back to face me directly. “You really need to sit down and listen to me right now.” “I listened to your toxic advice fifty-five years ago, and look where it got me!” I fired back immediately.