“Well,” he said. Loud, because he doesn’t hear well. “I never turned down a roast beef in my life.”
And people laughed.
They laughed the way you laugh when you’ve been holding your breath too long. And then they started standing up.
My niece Emma was six, and she was my flower girl. She came over and tugged on my dress. Her little basket was still full.
“Aunt Amy Jo? Do I still get to throw my petals?”
“You surely do,” I said. “You can throw them at the hall. You can throw them wherever you want.”
If you’ve never been in the VFW hall in Chanute, Kansas, it looks like every VFW hall you’ve ever been in. Brown paneling. Drop ceiling. The flags lined up along the west wall, and the black POW flag by the door. A kitchen with a pass-through window. And the canteen on the other side of a door that stays shut during family doings.
The post had let Daddy have the hall for just the cleaning deposit. Thirty years of dues and Friday fish fries will get you that.
The auxiliary ladies had been in there Friday with Beth and me, and they’d done what could be done. White paper streamers swagged from the middle of the ceiling out to the corners. Long rows of tables with white plastic covers and mason jars full of mums from Aunt Deb’s yard. A head table across the front with twelve chairs.
On the two chairs in the middle, somebody had tied big white bows.
I untied one of them myself and stuck it in a mason jar.
Connie met me at the kitchen door. She runs the cafe out on the highway and caters out of the back of it. She had four high school girls in black aprons and six steam pans going. She already knew. In a town of nine thousand people, news can get across four blocks faster than a bride can.
“Honey,” she said. “You tell me what you want. I can hold it. I can box it up. I can carry it down to the shelter in Parsons. Your dad’s not getting a nickel back from me, because I already spent it on beef. But I’ll do anything else you say.”
“I want you to open the line at five thirty, like we planned.”
“You want to sit down and let me bring you a plate?”
“No,” I said. “I want a spoon.”
I couldn’t have told you why, exactly. I only knew I couldn’t sit up at that head table next to an empty chair with a bow on it and be stared at. If a hundred and forty people were going to look at me, and they were, then I wanted something in my hands. I wanted to hand each one of them a hot plate.
Connie looked at me a long second. Then she tied an apron around my waist, right over the wedding dress, and handed me the long serving spoon for the beef.
So that’s where I was at 5:30. Standing at the head of the buffet line in a white wedding dress and canvas sneakers, with beef juice up to my wrist.
Harold Dawson was first in line. Naturally. He’d been standing by the stack of plates since 5:15.
“Give me an end piece if you’ve got one,” he said.
“I’ve got one.”
I laid it on his plate and handed it across. He didn’t move along. He stood there holding that plate in both hands, and he looked at me with his pale old eyes.
“I got a letter in Korea,” he said. “Winter of fifty-one. From a girl I’d been writing to since basic training. She’d married a fella from Fredonia.”
He nodded slowly.
“Thought it’d kill me. Then I met Dorothy at a box supper the year I got home. We had fifty-eight years.”
“Thank you, Harold.”
“I’m just telling you what happened,” he said, and he shuffled off down the line toward the potatoes.
They came through like that for forty minutes.
The pharmacy girls hugged me across the steam pans and got gravy on their sleeves. Daddy’s friends from the post couldn’t think of a thing to say, so they all said “looks good” about the beef. Derrick’s Aunt Judy took my free hand and held it against her cheek for a second and couldn’t say anything at all.
Emma threw petals at every single one of them.
And at about ten minutes to six, with sixty people still in line, the door by the POW flag opened.
Lorna came in.
PART 2: The Ring
She’d changed her shoes, I noticed. She’d worn navy heels at the church. Now she had on flats. She was still in the navy dress with the matching jacket. The one she and I had driven all the way to Joplin together to find. Her purse hung on her arm and her car keys were in her hand.
She didn’t look around. She came straight up the side of the room along the paneling, right past the whole line.
The band wasn’t playing yet. So when the talking died down, table by table, as people saw her, there was nothing to cover the quiet.
She stopped across the steam table from me.
Lorna was sixty-two. She’d been a widow for eight years. She’s a small, upright, careful woman who irons her pillowcases. And in the four years I’d dated her son, she had never once been unkind to me.
That was the part I couldn’t get past, standing there.
She taught me her mother’s noodle recipe. She sat with me at the hospital in Wichita for six nights the week my own mother died, because Derrick had to work.
“Amy Jo,” she said.
“Lorna.”
“I’ll take the ring now. I’d just as soon not make a second trip.”
She said it quietly. But it was a quiet room.
The ring was her mother’s. A small round diamond in a yellow gold setting from 1948. Derrick hadn’t bought it. Lorna had taken it out of her own jewelry box and handed it to him to give to me, and she’d cried while she did it.
I was never going to keep that ring. There was no version of that day where I kept it.
But it was also on my left hand. And my left hand was wrapped around a serving spoon, dripping with beef juice, in front of a hundred and forty people.
I could feel every one of them waiting to see what kind of person I was going to be.
Up at the head table, Daddy had started to rise. I caught his eye and shook my head. Just barely. He stopped where he was.
I picked a clean plate off the stack.
“You’ll have it tonight,” I said. “In its box. Wiped clean. The way your mother would have kept it. I’m not going to pull it off my finger over a steam pan and hand it to you greasy.”
Her mouth went tight. “I don’t think that’s for you to—”
“I’m serving supper right now, Lorna. There’s sixty people behind you.”
I laid a slice of beef on the plate. Then a second one, because she never takes enough.
“There’s a place for you at the head table,” I said. “It’s the same one that was always going to be yours. And there’s cake after. I’d like you to stay for it.”
She looked at that plate as if I’d held out a snake.
“I am not going to sit up there and—”
“Lorna.”
That wasn’t me.
It was her sister Judy, three places back in line. She didn’t say it loud.
“Your whole family is in this room,” Judy said. “Every one of us. We’re going to sit down and eat this girl’s supper, because she asked us to, and because it’s the least we can do. You can sit with us. Or you can go sit out in that car by yourself.”
She paused.
“But I’ll tell you which one people are going to remember.”
Lorna stood there.
I think she’d figured on a half-empty hall. A crying girl. A quick errand. Instead there was her own sister in the buffet line. Her own daughter Tammy at a table with the bridesmaids. And her son Jeff over by the wall, still in his best man’s suit, looking at his mother like he was asking her for something.
If she left now, she’d be leaving alone. In front of all of them.
She put her keys in her purse.
She took the plate.
“Potatoes are next,” I said. “Tell Connie’s girl to give you the corner. That’s the crispy part.”
I served until the very last person had come through. Then Connie took the spoon right out of my hand, put a plate in its place, and told me she’d come after me with a dish towel if I didn’t go sit down.
So I went up and sat at the head table after all.
Somebody had quietly taken away the other chair with the bow. I never found out who. Grandma June was on my left. Daddy was on my right.
And on the other side of Daddy, because it was the place that had always been hers, sat Lorna. Back as straight as a yardstick. Her beef cut into little pieces she wasn’t eating.
Nobody at that table said one cross word to her.
I’ve heard this story told back to me around town with things added to it, and that’s one of them. People say somebody gave her a piece of their mind. Nobody did. Daddy passed her the rolls. Grandma June asked after her tomatoes. Beth refilled her iced tea.
That was harder on her than a cross word would have been. I could see it on her face.
If somebody had lit into her, she’d have had something to stand up against. Instead she had to sit there and be passed the butter by the very people she’d sent a bill to. In front of a hundred and forty neighbors who all knew about that envelope by then.
About halfway through supper, she set her fork down.
“Ray,” she said. Low. “I expect you saw what I sent.”
“I did.”
“I put that cruise on my own credit card. Sixty-nine hundred dollars. It sails Monday out of Galveston, and they won’t give back a dime this close.” Her voice had a shake in it that she was working hard to hold down. “I don’t have that, Ray. I have never in my life carried a balance. I don’t know what I’m going to do.”
Daddy picked up a roll and buttered it. He took his time.
“Lorna, I’m going to say this one time,” he said. “And then I’m not going to say it again. Not tonight. Not ever.”
He didn’t raise his voice. He’s never needed to.
“A supper got eaten last night by thirty-eight people, and you and I were two of them. A boat’s going to sail Monday whether anybody’s on it or not. My girl didn’t order either one. And she didn’t cancel either one. You’ve brought it to the wrong house.”
Lorna looked down at her plate.
“I’ve got sixty-four hundred dollars in this room myself,” Daddy said, more gently now. “I’m not sending anybody an envelope. I’m sitting here watching Harold Dawson go back for thirds. I figure I got my money’s worth.”
He set the buttered roll on her bread plate.
That was the last time I ever heard anybody speak of the nine thousand dollars.
A little later, Jeff came up behind my chair and crouched down next to me, the way you’d do to talk to somebody at a ball game.
“He texted me again,” he said. “You want to know or not?”
I thought about it. “Is it short?”
“Yeah.”
“Go ahead.”
Jeff read it off his phone. Derrick had left the lake and driven south down Highway 169 to their cousin’s place in Tulsa. He said he’d known since spring that he didn’t want to get married. He kept thinking the feeling would pass. And every week it got harder to say out loud, until that morning it was just easier to drive.
That was the whole reason.
There was no other woman. There was no big secret. There was just a man too scared to have one hard conversation back in April.
“Okay,” I said.
“You want me to say anything back?”
“Tell him his mother’s here. And she’s eating.”
Jeff almost smiled. “That’ll scare him worse than anything.”
“I’m not trying to scare him,” I said. “I just think he ought to know where she is.”