Our Family Lake Party Turned Into a Nightmare When My Brother Returned Without My Daughter. Then Dad Told Me Not to Call the Police…

Part 3

The stranger’s name was Dale Pruitt, a retired fireman from Jefferson City, and the woman beside him, his wife, wrapped Winnie in a beach towel and then in a fleece blanket and held her tight against her chest, humming under her breath.

“Her temperature’s low but she’s talking,” Dale said. “That’s good. I called it in. Sheriff’s marine patrol is two minutes out, and there’s an ambulance at the public dock.”

I sat on the deck of that pontoon with my arms around my daughter, shaking so hard my teeth hurt.

The marine patrol boat arrived a few minutes later, white and blue, lights flashing. A deputy, a woman in her forties with a braid, climbed aboard, checked Winnie’s pulse and pupils, and said the words I had been waiting to hear:

“She’s going to be fine, ma’am. She’s cold and scared, but she’s okay.”

I nodded, and kept nodding.

“Ma’am, I need to ask,” she said gently. “Your son called dispatch, and he said the driver of the jet ski was intoxicated?”

“My nephew. Yes. My brother.”

“Is he still at your parents’ dock?”

“He was.”

She spoke into her radio. Then she looked at me.

“We’ll take your daughter to the ambulance first. Then I’d like you to tell me exactly what happened.”

I told her all of it.

I told her about the four minutes. About my mother waving her drink. About my father grabbing my shoulder. About the life jacket in Rhett’s hand, and she didn’t want to wear it. I told her what my father said, and what my mother said.

The deputy didn’t write that down at first. She just listened. Then she wrote all of it.

Part 4

By the time the ambulance took Winnie to Lake Regional, a crowd had gathered on my parents’ dock.

My nephew, Sam, had done exactly what I’d asked. He’d called 911 and used every word. Then, according to a neighbor, he had stood on the dock holding my phone with both hands, tears running down his face, while my father yelled at him to hang up.

He hadn’t.

Sam found me in the hospital hallway an hour later, still in his swim trunks, a towel around his shoulders. He was sixteen and thin and looked ten.

“Aunt Gwen,” he said. “I’m sorry. I should’ve gone after Uncle Rhett sooner. I saw him drinking. I saw him take her.”

“Sam. Look at me.” I put my hands on his shoulders. “You did the one thing I needed. You called. You said the words. You did exactly right.”

“Grandpa said I was ruining everything.”

“Grandpa was wrong.”

He started to cry again. I held him in a hallway that smelled of antiseptic and floor wax, and I thought of how my father had grabbed my shoulder, and how I’d been taught to be quiet for thirty-eight years.

Winnie came through it fine. A cold, a little water in her lungs, a night of observation, and a nurse who let her pick out a sticker for each finger prick. She wore a hospital bracelet with a cartoon whale on it, and she wouldn’t let me out of her sight.

“Mommy,” she said, near midnight, her small hand curled in mine. “Is Uncle Rhett in trouble?”

“Yes.”

“Because of me?”

“No, sweetheart. Because of what he did.”

She considered this.

“I did what you said,” she whispered. “I found something that floats.”

“You did,” I said. “You saved yourself, Winnie. And I came.”

Part 5

Rhett was arrested at the dock that evening.

He’d had a blood alcohol level of 0.19 when the deputy tested him, nearly two and a half times the legal limit. He’d also, according to two neighbors and the marine patrol’s review, been operating the watercraft recklessly in a crowded no-wake zone for most of the afternoon.

He was charged with boating while intoxicated, child endangerment, and reckless operation of a vessel. Because of his two prior DUI convictions, the prosecutor, a calm, careful man named Mr. Holloway, told me the penalties could be severe.

“It’s going to be hard,” he said. “Your family will pressure you.”

“They already have.”

My mother called eleven times in the first day. The first message was furious. The second was hurt. By the sixth, she was weeping.

Gwen, please. He’s your brother. You’ve ruined his life over one mistake.

I did not call back.

My father called once, late on the second night. I answered, because I wanted to hear what he would say.

“Gwen.” His voice was gruff. “I’d like you to talk to the prosecutor. Ask him to go easy.”

“Dad. He threw my seven-year-old into the middle of a lake and left her.”

“She wasn’t hurt.”

“Because she was brave. Because she remembered a rule I taught her.”

“He’s your brother…”

“And she’s your granddaughter.”

Silence.

“You told me not to call the police,” I said. “With my child in the water.”

“I was thinking about Rhett.”

“I know,” I said. “That’s the problem.”

I hung up. My hands were steady. I hadn’t known they could be.

Part 6

The hearing was in September.

Rhett wore a gray suit that didn’t quite fit. He had lost weight. He looked, for the first time I could remember, like a man who understood the thing in front of him.

His lawyer argued that Rhett was a troubled man with an alcohol problem who deserved treatment, not prison. The judge listened, a heavyset man with a gravelly voice and a pair of reading glasses perched on his forehead.

I testified for forty minutes. I described the four minutes, the swim, the hair tie. I described my daughter’s blue lips.