Luke believed he had erased Caroline’s connection to her sister for good. Then Beth’s voice came through the hospital phone after nearly three years apart. Suddenly, Luke wasn’t controlling the conversation anymore.

The line picked up almost immediately, and my sister’s voice came through the nurse’s phone while Luke stood several feet away with nothing left to interrupt.

Her name was Beth.

I had not heard her voice in almost three years.

The nurse held the phone near my bed, and Beth said my name once, stopped, then asked whether I could hear her.

I moved two fingers against the sheet.

Barely anything.

Enough.

Luke stepped toward us and told the nurse that family calls exhausted me, but she raised one hand without looking at him and kept the phone where it was.

The room was cold enough that my uncovered fingertips ached, and somewhere outside the door a cart rolled over a bad wheel with the same soft click every few seconds.

Beth started asking questions.

Not about Luke.

About me.

Could I speak?

Was I awake?

Did I know where I was?

I answered when I could.

Yes.

Yes.

Hospital.

Luke tried again.

“She needs rest,” he said. “Her sister has always made these situations worse.”

Beth heard him.

The silence on the phone changed.

Then she said, “Put the doctor back on.”

Luke’s face tightened.

The doctor took the phone and moved toward the window, speaking quietly while I watched Luke watch her.

He could not hear every word.

Neither could I.

That bothered him more than shouting would have.

He had spent years making sure every conversation involving me passed through him first.

He answered my phone.

He read messages over my shoulder.

He told people when I was too tired to talk, too emotional to visit, too sick to travel, too confused to remember.

Now people were speaking about my safety while he stood outside the conversation.

I watched him reach for his own phone.

I watched the nurse notice.

I watched her move between him and my bed.

He lowered it.

The doctor returned several minutes later and told Luke that the hospital needed to speak with me privately.